Will the Maryland Purple Line Appear on the Washington DC Metrorail Map?

New York & New Jersey Subway Map shows how we can give people a comprehensive view of transit options in the NYC region. In the Washington DC metro area, a similar issue will soon be under consideration: whether to include the Maryland Purple Line on the Washington DC Metrorail Map. The Maryland Purple Line is a proposed 16-mile light rail line that would link Bethesda and New Carrolton, with connections to the Washington DC Metrorail Red, Green, and Orange lines.

As the line moves closer to construction, Greater Greater Washington contributor Peter Dovak asks Will the Purple Line appear on the Metro map? Continues…

Transit Hubs: Catalysts for the Urban Economy

Transit hubs in the New York area have long been catalysts for the growth of their surrounding neighborhoods, and the shared economy of the NY & NJ urban core. Five terminals were constructed along the New Jersey shore of the Hudson River during the rail boom of the late 19th Century: Weehawken Terminal, Hoboken Terminal, Pavonia Terminal, Exchange Place, and Communipaw Terminal.

West Shore Railroad Terminal, Weehawken, NJ. c. 1911

West Shore Railroad Terminal, Weehawken, NJ. c. 1911

On the New York side, Erastus Corning’s New York Central Railroad built Grand Central Station, the precursor to the Grand Central Terminal that stands as a landmark today. By 1910, Pennsylvania Station became the seventh major passenger rail station serving New York City and its urban surroundings. Continues…

Philadelphia’s Transit Map, Managed by SEPTA, Includes PATCO Speedline to NJ

When public transit agencies collaborate and build maps that display each other’s services, riders benefit. For example, the Philadelphia Rail Transit Map shows rapid transit services provided by two agencies: Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA), which operates most lines, and Delaware River Port Authority, which operates the PATCO Line connecting Philadelphia with Camden and several other points in New Jersey. The SEPTA map key includes the disclaimer “not a SEPTA service” next to the PATCO Line, but represents the line using a visual style consistent with all other rapid transit lines in Philadelphia.

Closeup: PATCO Speedline on SEPTA Rail Transit Map

NYC Subway Map Displays AirTrain JFK; Sets Precedent for Including PATH

Subway NY NJ proposes more prominently displaying ‘New York’s second subway”–PATH to New Jersey–on the NYC Subway map, for a more complete map of transit in the NY & NJ urban core. The map has a long history of including NJ subway connections. The current subway map also prominently displays AirTrain JFK, which connects terminals at John F. Kennedy International Airport with the A Train at Howard Beach, and the E, J, Z, and Long Island Rail Road at Jamaica. Like PATH, AirTrain JFK is operated by the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey.

AirTrain JFK on Subway Map

The presence of AirTrain JFK on the NYC subway map sets a precedent for including other non-MTA transit services that directly connect to the subway system, accept the pay-per-ride MetroCard for fare payment, and serve transit needs in the urban core. PATH meets this threshold in all three ways: it is even more centrally located in the urban core than AirTrain JFK, also accepts the pay-per-ride MetroCard, and connects to 18 subway lines: B,D,F,M at 33rd, F,M at 23rd, 1,2,3,L,F,M at 14th, and 2,3,4,5,A,C,J,Z, and R at Fulton Center.

PATH to Newark Airport is a Great Idea

On a recent fall morning, I awoke to two helicopters buzzing overhead. A quick check of Twitter confirmed my suspicion: mounting delays at the inbound Lincoln Tunnel because of a crash in one of the tubes. The likelihood that travel on New York-area roads can suddenly come to a screeching halt, especially during morning and evening rush, is a major reason why we need to invest in public transit, especially to increase cross-Hudson capacity.

I was thinking about those morning Lincoln Tunnel delays when I left the office recently to catch an evening flight from Newark Airport to Chicago. I decided to take PATH from World Trade Center to Newark Penn Station, followed by a quick transfer to NJ Transit for the roughly two-mile-long, one-stop trip to Newark Airport. It’s a trip I’ve taken regularly for years, and at about 45 minutes, it’s generally shorter than the trip to LaGuardia or JFK. But it can be unpredictable.

A few years ago, I arrived at Newark Airport on a Sunday evening. NJ Transit was running service only every 30 minutes, so I tried taking a taxi from the airport to Newark Penn to catch PATH. Thanks to traffic, I spent more than a half hour in traffic on a trip up Lincoln Highway that should have taken no more than 10 minutes. NJ Transit runs two bus services connecting the airport with downtown Newark. The 62 bus is a local route and trip time is equally unpredictable in traffic, while the 28 Go bus, similar in concept to the MTA’s limited-stop Select Bus Service, doesn’t leave from Newark Penn. One has to either walk or take Newark Light Rail to Broad St. Station, easily adding as much as 10-15 minutes to the trip. Once on board the 28, a trip to Terminal C, geographically closest to downtown Newark, adds another 16 minutes to the overall travel time.

This evening, I left WTC at 5:10 on a Newark-bound PATH train and arrived Newark Penn at 5:35. After buying an NJ Transit ticket, I boarded the 5:44 South Amboy-bound NJ Transit train, and exited the Newark Airport station turnstiles at 5:49, for a trip time of 39 minutes.

Extending PATH to Newark Airport has been proposed, debated, and scrutinized for years, but it’s a really good idea that’s long overdue. New York has fallen behind other leading global cities that have far better transit connections to their airports. Trains in Brussels terminate at a station directly below the main terminal, and elevators carry passengers to and from departure and arrival concourses in a multi-story structure. London has multiple direct connections. The Piccadilly Line provides Tube service, while Heathrow Express and Heathrow Connect provide rail service at varying price points and travel times. Shanghai has a maglev shuttling people between airport and city at impressive speeds.

An update on PATH to Newark Airport presented at the Port Authority’s April 2015 Board meeting shows that the project team isn’t just thinking of it as an airport-only service. PATH, infrastructure firm HNTB, and the Regional Plan Association are studying how new PATH service, combined with a revitalization plan for Newark’s Dayton neighborhood could lay the groundwork for new mixed-use development on the formerly industrial area adjacent to the proposed extension. Critics often argue that transit extensions to airports prioritize business travelers and tourists over local populations, but a look at PATH’s public materials reveals a forward-thinking approach to this already good idea that could make it into a unique success story for transit and community growth.

NY Officials, on Hudson River Tunnels: “It’s New Jersey, so Who Cares?”

On Sunday, NorthJersey.com published an opinion piece by Philip Mark Plotch that shed light on the political attitudes that have led to the precarious and deteriorating state of cross-Hudson transit. Plotch is well-placed to offer this insight: he was previously director of WTC Development for the Lower Manhattan Development Corporation, a joint city-state public entity created to plan redevelopment of Lower Manhattan after the September 11 attacks. He is currently professor and director of the MPA program at St. Peter’s University, and author of Politics Across the Hudson, a book about the megaproject to rebuild the Tappan Zee bridge.

While writing his book, Plotch interviewed numerous New York state officials to better understand why they didn’t promote Access to the Region’s Core (ARC), the cross-Hudson tunnel project canceled by New Jersey Governor Chris Christie in 2010. Their answers, Plotch says, “made my head spin.” Continues…

Amtrak, MTA, NJ Transit, Port Authority & RPA on Expanding Trans-Hudson Capacity

As delays and interruptions become more frequent in the century-old North River Tunnels connecting New York and New Jersey, and the political debate grows louder over who will pay for the two new tunnels proposed by Amtrak, some context on the issue is helpful.

In May, the Port Authority, MTA, NJ Transit, Regional Plan Association, and Amtrak jointly convened a Trans-Hudson Summit to discuss the needs, challenges, and solutions for NY & NJ transit infrastructure. The Port Authority also prepared a Profile of the Regional Interstate Transportation Network, a snapshot of trends and market patterns:

Manhattan’s extraordinary concentration of high-value jobs would not be possible without its access to a huge, diverse, and talented labor market over a large geographic area that its extensive transit network makes possible. Efficient public transit is essential to providing the regional mobility needed to sustain its economic competitiveness. And interstate commuting to employment sites outside Manhattan has been growing as well. Access to skilled workers means gains in productivity and profitability for area businesses and a growing standard of living for the entire region.

A Vital Link: Expanding Transportation Capacity Across the Hudson
May 7, 2015

The morning sessions began with a series of presentations from the sponsoring transportation agencies, each of which focused on different aspects of the trans-Hudson challenge. The presentations covered the changes in the volume and nature of trans-Hudson travel that have occurred over the past generation; the condition of the physical infrastructure and capacity constraints on the trans-Hudson crossings and facilities; and referenced potential solutions to expand transportation capacity for further discussion, including project costs and benefits.

Thomas K. Wright, President, Regional Plan Association

Andrew Lynn, Director, Planning & Regional Development, The Port Authority of New York & New Jersey
Drew Galloway, Chief of Planning & Performance, NECIID, Amtrak
Veronique Hakim, Executive Director, NJ TRANSIT
Rich Roberts, Chief, NEC Trans-Hudson Projects, NJ TRANSIT
Bill Wheeler, Director of Planning, Metropolitan Transportation Authority

A Vital Link: Expanding Transportation Capacity Across the Hudson
May 7, 2015

The second morning session began with remarks from the distinguished panelists listed below representing other partners in addressing the trans-Hudson challenge, who responded to the agency presentations. Then there was a moderated discussion of potential solutions and a process for moving forward.

Thomas K. Wright, President, Regional Plan Association

Distinguished Panelists:
Peter Rogoff, Under Secretary of Transportation for Policy, U.S. Department of Transportation
Joel Ettinger, Executive Director, New York Metropolitan Transportation Council
Mary K. Murphy, Executive Director, North Jersey Transportation Planning Authority
Martin Robins, Founding Director, Voorhees Transportation Center, Rutgers University

Amtrak Panelists:
Anthony Coscia, Chairman of the Board
Stephen Gardner, Vice President, NECIID
Drew Galloway, Chief of Planning & Performance, NECIID

New Jersey Panelists:
Veronique Hakim, Executive Director, NJ TRANSIT
Rich Roberts, Chief, NEC Trans-Hudson Projects, NJ TRANSIT

New York Panelists:
Polly Trottenberg, Commissioner, New York City Department of Transportation
Bill Wheeler, Director of Planning, Metropolitan Transportation Authority

Port Authority Panelists:
John Degnan, Chairman
Scott Rechler, Vice-Chairman
Patrick Foye, Executive Director
Andrew Lynn, Director, Planning & Regional Development

Regional Plan Association Panelist:
Elliot G. Sander, Chairman

A Vital Link: Expanding Transportation Capacity Across the Hudson
May 7, 2015

This panel discussed innovative financing models, including the role of public-private partnerships, in funding the massive capital investments required to substantially expand cross-Hudson transit capacity.

Rohit Aggarwala, Principal, Bloomberg Associates

D.J. Gribbin, Managing Director, Macquarie Group
Chris Ireland, Director of Infrastructure Investments, Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan
Sam Schwartz, President, CEO & Founder, Sam Schwartz Engineering
Robert Yaro, President Emeritus & Senior Advisor, Regional Plan Association

A Vital Link: Expanding Transportation Capacity Across the Hudson
May 7, 2015

This panel explored the project delivery process and the labor, regulatory and environment permitting involved in expanding cross-Hudson transit capacity, and possible strategies for “fast-tracking” necessary projects of national and regional significance.

Joshua Schank, President & CEO, Eno Center for Transportation

Mark Chertok, Principal, Sive, Paget & Riesel
Philip Howard, Chair, Common Good
Marilyn J. Taylor, Dean, School of Design, University of Pennsylvania

New York & New Jersey Subway Map

New York Subway Map with New Jersey transit systems, including Hudson-Bergen Light Rail, NY Waterway ferry, and PATH, made by Stewart Mader.

The New York Subway Map influences the transit choices of over 2.4 billion riders, and has a long history of including New Jersey, as well as other transit options that supplement the subway, but the current map doesn’t include all options that serve the city and its immediate environs. That’s why I created this New York & New Jersey Subway Map. A comprehensive map can help people choose transit options that reduce stress, ease congestion and pollution, and increase safety for everyone. Maps in major cities like Berlin, London, Philadelphia, and Tokyo include all rapid transit services, regardless of operator.

What’s on the Map?


I interviewed transit riders in New York’s Fulton Center subway station about the New York & New Jersey Subway Map. Jonn Elledge and Barbara Speed interviewed me about the project on Skylines, the CityMetric podcast. It has also been covered by CityMetric, Gothamist, hMAG, NJ.com, Patch, Reddit, Transitism, and Transit Maps, and received the endorsement of the mayors of Hoboken and Jersey City.


After creating the New York & New Jersey Subway Map, I worked with the Port Authority of New York & New Jersey to create PATH Riders Council (PRC), an advisory group for the subway system connecting New York & New Jersey. Among our accomplishments is an updated PATH map that shows transit connections available at or near each PATH station. This new map helps PATH customers plan their trips using all available transit options, and moves the region closer to the more comprehensive New York & New Jersey Subway Map. I presented the updated PATH map to the Port Authority Board of Commissioners in 2016 to highlight collaboration between PATH & PRC, and emphasize the value of giving customers comprehensive information about transit.


In an interview with PIX11 reporter Greg Mocker, I was critical of a 2014 proposal to cut overnight PATH subway service.


In 2014, I made the case for a New York & New Jersey transit map to the MTA Transportation Reinvention Commission.


Historically, geographically, and commercially New York and the industrial district in the northern part of the state of New Jersey constitute a single community. –Interstate Commerce Commission

NYC Subway Maps Have a Long History of Including PATH, NJ Waterfront

Subway NY NJ proposes more prominently displaying ‘New York’s second subway”–PATH to New Jersey–on the NYC Subway map, for a better map of transit in the NY & NJ urban core. There’s a precedent for this idea: subway maps in New York City have a long history of including the Hudson Waterfront and subway connections between New York and New Jersey.

Although the Hudson & Manhattan railroad (the precursor to PATH) was still under construction and revenue service wouldn’t begin until 1908, the 1906 Interborough Rapid Transit (IRT) map showed the New Jersey waterfront, with Hoboken and Jersey City labeled, and ferry routes connecting NY & NJ:

IRT 1906 subway map

After the IRT, BMT, and Independent Subway System (IND) were consolidated into a single system, the 1944 NYC Board of Transportation map included the Jersey City waterfront, H&M lines labeled “Hudson Tubes (to Newark)”, stations in Manhattan, and Exchange Place station in New Jersey:

1944 board of transportation map

This 1950 NYC Board of Transportation map shows the Hudson & Manhattan railroad and New Jersey waterfront in much the same way as the proposed Subway NY NJ map:

1950 board of transportation map

A 1968 map produced by the Irving Trust Company displayed the PATH Tubes, and stations represented with black dots, but did not include labels containing station names. It also included an unlabeled outline of the Hudson Waterfront:

1968 irving trust map

The 1969 New York City Transit Authority map didn’t show PATH tubes and stations, but did display the Hudson waterfront, labeled “New Jersey”:

1969 nycta map

New Jersey and PATH were excluded from the 1972 map designed by Massimo Vignelli. A small portion of the Hudson Waterfront, labeled “New Jersey” reappeared on the 1979 map, and was on the map as recently as 1987:

1987 MTA Subway Map

Bringing it back, and improving how PATH is represented, will give 1.8 billion annual transit riders a more complete picture of rail rapid transit service in the urban core of New York and New Jersey.

On the SubChat website, Michael549 commented:

The “Subway Map” is not “just the subways”, but an opportunity to provide a means for telling folks how to get about the city. In recent years the MAP has called it, “The Map”. In any case, the “subway map” has for decades been a well used representation of the city. It provides a means for folks to try and figure out where they are, and where they want to go. Which of course has lead to countless arguments about what to include, how to include it or depict it, what not to include, etc. Inside the Transit Museum there are displays about how the “subway map” has changed over the decades. This particular argument is about how to include and depict the PATH system. On one level it is really not that far removed from arguments in the past about what should or should not appear on the maps. Anyone remember past subway maps where only a particular company’s routes were shown on “their maps”- the IND only maps, the IRT only maps, the BMT only maps? Anyone remember the complaints over the shape of Central Park in previous maps? The MAP is not just about the subway, but about the ability to help folks navigate their way around the city – that is the real important goal to not lose sight of.

Complete Streets Construction to Begin on Newark Street & Observer Boulevard

In her 2015 State of the City address, Hoboken Mayor Dawn Zimmer announced that construction would begin this spring on major improvements to Newark Street and Observer Highway. Last week, the city confirmed that construction would begin April 27th.

Observer Boulevard

Newark Street is part of a major pedestrian artery connecting Hoboken Terminal, the city’s primary transit gateway, and Washington Street, the city’s central business district. It is heavily trafficked by pedestrians walking to and from Hoboken Terminal, especially during weekday morning and evening rush periods, leading to congested sidewalks, crowded intersections that spill into the street, and conflict between turning vehicles and pedestrians who have the right-of-way to cross.

One block south of Newark Street, Observer Highway is one of the primary streets connecting Hoboken with Jersey City and the Holland Tunnel. The “highway” in Observer Highway is a truism. The street is a wide, forbidding expanse for pedestrians to attempt to cross, with two travel lanes in each direction, parking lanes on both sides, and no traffic signals between Washington Street and Willow Avenue. These conditions set driver expectations for a fast, unimpeded, highway-like experience, which then lead to complaints that the street is an inadequate thoroughfare when traffic speeds don’t meet driver expectations.

Complete Streets design can do much to address the types of street conditions found on Newark and Observer. By appropriately balancing the needs of bicyclists, drivers, and pedestrians, a complete street sets better expectations for everyone. Clear markings for travel, turning, and bike lanes help drivers see the street as a shared space. Designated bike lanes provide a safe space for cyclists, and reduce the conflict with pedestrians that happens when unsafe streets force cyclists to use sidewalks. Curb extensions provide extra space for large volumes of pedestrians to wait safely at intersections, reduce the distance for pedestrians to cross streets, and make vehicle turns safer and slower by enforcing a wider turning radius.

These types of improvements are the focus of the Newark Street and Observer Highway project. Between Washington and Hudson Streets, Newark Street will be converted from asphalt to cobblestone, curb extensions will be added, and a public plaza with chairs, tables, and trees will anchor the southeast corner of the intersection with Washington Street. Between Marin Boulevard and Hoboken Terminal, Observer Highway will be reconstructed with one travel lane in each direction, designated turning lanes at intersections, traffic signals at Bloomfield Street and Park Avenue, curb extensions for shorter crossing distances, and a two-way protected bike lane. This project, together with the First Street streetscape and citywide wayfinding improvement project, are bringing significant improvements to three of Hoboken’s heavily used southern streets.

« Previous PageNext Page »